It is indeed very unfortunate that the Idea Star Singer continues to be farce.First of all, when u call aprogramme for singers, u should not allow diversions like dance, dabbam koothu etc helping the weaker contestants to cover up thier follies.; it should be purely music alone; look at the similar programmes in other channels- they do not even recognise malayalam as as alanguage which could give any good songs at all; though we should not stoop so low-we must also encourage more songs in malayalam only and restrict other languagaes like tamil/ hindi etc to a a few rounds; the candudates should all belong to a similar group ie if u are finding young talent all contestants shoulkd be amateurs and not like Senior artistes lke Kalpana , the sponosored.She had put up a horrible performance but was allowed a repreive in consideration of her tricks with tears etc;; etc. Pleasze think of the real amateur participants who also would have pleaded for a repreive when they put up a lack-lustre performance in a single episode.they also would have made u p to reach and win the finals. It is anyway good that this time they ignored SMS and went for judge's decision.But unfortunately the judges were highly intimidated by the American slave Yesudas.Unfair! In the past they had played dirty with SMS and overshadowed ther judges. Let them always depend on judges- that too with no prompting from the likes of Yesudas. use SMS onle for statistics and to measure the deviation in the judgements of the judges and the people.
Talking of American slavery- it is an unfortunate curse on Indian vbrain and talent.Remember Pandit Ravishankar the renowned Sitarist.Nowadays he is not seen or heard as he is working as a slave by playing the junior accompanist of the US experimentalist.Yesudas also is known to have started such petty roles. Good to praise your masters , slaves but do not change change your parents!
Dear All,I have different opinion on this two mails.....What Gangadharan said is right, kalpana had a peculiar face expression at the time of judgment…..But the narration about that, it's all about perceptions I believe…When you quoted it as Selfishness…hatred…I feel it as her complete nervousness and tension expressed on her face……Ultimately all contestants in Idea star singer is not coming for devotional love to music???All final target is to win prize? Publicity??TITLE?? Can u accept sir?Y idea star singer have more contestants ??bcoz the prize money is very high????Right?? So who is not selfish……And to Kalpana…her necessity was more…..not like others…for them its win or lose in a big music competition..but for kalpana..it was her target…She want money, she want home….she clearly expressed her struggles many time……that she want to win coz she want her daughter to be secure. Its obvious for any contestant to be very nervous, when they are one feet away from judgment..But mridula is cool in nature, and she was able to handle it….but to Kalpana, she treated the prize more than and she indeed made a very bold attempt of music in final rounds??right? so let her win…….y such comments??And One important things to Naina also….Malayalis might be matured, brilliant than other states, but have you noticed the fact that our music and film never gain popularity in other states like we hear Tamil or other language songs??? Here.... be thankful to Kalpana…she came…she tried to sung our good Malayalam songs…she took some songs to Chennai too…….now Tamil people listen and know more about music in Malayalam…., Tis all hapened only coz one Tamil girl gave an attempt to sing in our malaylam program??? So is Kalpana done wrong or good?and indeed she entertained us???Idea star singer always gave marks for performance too?can you tell its 100% music show??No......Its music+performance show....acting skills gives you marks?? Am I right??Personal gain and selfish is for all of us Gangadhar….only the intensity varies…..For Kalpana, she want to win, no other choice to save her life from troubles. So understand….her facial expresiions showd her nervousness...And now about the logic of sms????Y people msging to contetants ??all msgonly for good songs??I know the contestants requesting all village, all school, all college mates to sms? Though they like the song or not, they will sms for their place contestant? so y kalpana got less sms? Bcoz she is not from kerala? only reason is that i will say..So SMS is to Song??? Or to contestant??We had an efficient panel of judges..so let the marks decide? Y sms??And sms marketing? Yes..if u msged its bcoz u dint understand the branding techniques..u lost.. :-)When am speaking this much…don't doubt me as "Chennai spy" of Kalpana.. :-)Am a girl from Mridulas place, now am in Chennai and am happy Malayalam songs spreading here thru Kalpana…..To be truthful .loving Mridulas sweet voice and maturity more than the winner…but expressed my opinions..That all your honor… JWhoever win or lose…only good music will survive.,….and passionate artists…Kaalam ennum athu theliyichittundu........With Love Regards...
Varsha....'d rain
"Smile to Life...Life will Smile back."
Sent: Monday, 26 September 2011 12:08 AMDear friends,What my frined written below about the SMS is right , if the judjement is according to the judges then why repeateldy asking the SMS and who ever send SMS for their favoirate singer they become fool more over waste of money by sending SMS , Kalpana she become popular only because of her acting not in her singing , in the begining she was not femilier with the malayalam words. If relly the channel want to help then more SMS is for ANTONY . why the channel dint consider about the audience who send SMS which help to get more money for IDEA . the least vote was for KALPANA . More over I appriciate MRIDULA about her charecter , personality till her last song. I AM VERY MUCH PROUD TO BE A KERLAITE . from the biggining it was understood that the judjing pannel will give for KALPANA only because of sympathy . Audience send SMS for Antony for the same sympathy.but Idea who make money dind see this. any how this is a business , atlease give prizes for the needy.Immanual , akhil, deepak , Mridula , you are good singers not a actors. Belive in GOD keep on practising you will reach the distination . more over you all are well educated children which you can be proud .
AND more over you all are from KERALA GODS OWN COUNTRY. MY SPECIAL CONGRATULATIONS FOR MRIDUALA ,,,,,,,From: Gangadharan KV <kvgananya@gmail.com>
To: Keralites <Keralites@yahoogroups.com>
Sent: Sunday, September 25, 2011 1:17 PM
Subject: [www.keralites.net] Idea Star Singer Season 5 Grand Finale
To subscribe send a mail to Keralites-subscribe@yahoogroups.com.
Send your posts to Keralites@yahoogroups.com.
Send your suggestions to Keralites-owner@yahoogroups.com.
To unsubscribe send a mail to Keralites-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com.
Homepage: www.keralites.net
No comments:
Post a Comment